How Do You Make Toast In a Toaster Oven?

January 3, 2023
Related Categories: 

Using a Toaster Oven to Make Toast

Before there were toasters, there were iron heaters. And now, we have evolved to using toaster ovens, the most efficient appliance for making every slice of toast to your liking.

One of the most versatile tools to toast bread in any modern-day kitchen, the toaster oven can be a smart alternative for your slow, standard full-sized ovens or your more basic toasters with vertical racks when making toast. Some people like toasting bread slices on their oven racks, but the toaster oven can help to save time, energy, and space.

The toaster oven is loved by many for its ease of use, smaller size and ability to toast bread quickly. This has made it one of the most popular registry items and housewarming gifts on the market today. Some restaurants have even adopted the use of toaster ovens in place of their much slower and more costly appliances.

However, if you’ve never used a toaster oven before, it can be a daunting task to figure out the many heating options, and even making simple toast can seem complicated at first. So, let’s answer the question “How do you make toast in a toaster oven?”

Whether you’re just starting to test out your new toaster oven or looking for a way to streamline your breakfast routine, we can help you to make the most of your toaster oven. We will discuss the things to keep in mind when making toast, provide some basic instructions for how to use your oven, list the benefits of using a toaster oven, and mention some of the other uses for your toaster oven to consider in the future so that you can become a toaster oven expert in no time.

Achieve Perfectly Toasted Bread Using a Toaster Oven

The Intricacies of Making Toast

While making toast sounds easy, many things can impact the quality of your bread, such as the level of browning, the type of bread used, and the quality of the appliance used. These are a few things to keep in mind when making toast in your toaster oven, and these will help you make your toast even more delicious. Here are some important factors that help you answer the question “How do you make toast in a toaster oven?


Have you ever wondered why toast tastes better than regular bread? People first started toasting their bread as early as 1430 but only recently discovered that toasting the bread changes the taste due to a chemical reaction known as the Maillard Reaction.

This change in taste allows for a wide array of preferences when it comes to how long to toast a slice of bread. Most people prefer their toast to be only slightly toasted, with a golden-brown color. But some people like a more burnt toast for the crispier texture.


A good slice of toast not only depends on your taste but also on the quality of your tools and the ingredients used.

While most toaster ovens are adjustable to ensure a perfect level of toastiness, some toaster ovens are just better at it. The type of toaster oven you use can make a difference in the quality of your toast and the time needed to make your dish.

The quality of your ingredients matters, too. An old, stale slice of bread will still be an old, stale slice of bread after toasting it. If you want toast that can make the whole family proud, try to use fresh, quality bread. You can even spice it up by using a less common type of bread, such as whole wheat or brioche variety, or making your own.

Toaster Ovens Can Make Toasting Bread More Efficient

Making the Perfect Piece of Toast

While there are many ways to enjoy your toast, these basic instructions will provide a step-by-step guide to making golden, lightly-toasted bread in your toaster oven. If you want a crispier toast, you can increase the time cooked by increments of one minute until the bread slice has been toasted to your liking.

Step 1: Preheat the Toaster Oven

The first step to achieving your perfect slice of toast is preheating your toaster oven. Preheating your oven allows for an even bake, and can reduce the time required to toast your bread. Some convection toaster ovens may not need to be preheated, as they typically heat up faster and cook your food more quickly by evenly circulating heat generated by the heating element of the toaster oven.

If the toaster oven calls for a temperature, you should set it to around 400 degrees Fahrenheit, or medium-high heat. If your toaster oven has a toast setting, you can always use that too.

Step 2: Place Your Bread and Start Toasting

Next, you will want to place your bread into the toaster oven on a pan or a baking sheet, or you can toss the toast straight onto the rack. Placing your toast directly on the rack may create lines in your bread from the bars, but otherwise, it doesn’t make a difference in cooking. It is crucial, though, to place your bread onto the rack or pan closest to the top of the oven, which allows your toast to cook more quickly.

Then you can turn the toaster oven to the broil setting. This setting uses the least amount of energy by utilizing only the topmost heating mechanics that are now directly above your bread.

Keep your bread in the toaster oven like this for about 2 to 3 minutes. This time will vary depending on the amount of toast, the type of toaster oven, and your preferences, so keep an eye on your toast the first few times you do it.

Step 3: Flip the Toast

Once you see that your bread has been toasted well on the top side, you can flip your bread with tongs or a fork and continue toasting for another 2 to 3 minutes until the toast is completely done. This step can be repeated, as needed until you are satisfied with the end product.

Feel free to experiment with your toaster oven settings even more to get a slice of toast tailored to your individual preferences. Some high-quality toasters include settings specifically made for toast, so getting to know your toaster oven can help simplify the process, too.

The Benefits of Using a Toaster Oven

So why use a toaster oven over a standard toaster or a full-sized oven? There are many advantages to using a toaster oven including space availability, efficiency, and versatility. Some people even replace their other appliances with this one-of-a-kind kitchen tool.

A Miniature Oven on Your Countertop

This modern kitchen appliance is worth the hype as a small and efficient way to toast, broil, or bake small meals. Toaster ovens are miniature ovens that you can easily stow on your countertop or in a cabinet.

With some of the most popular toaster ovens holding up to nine slices of bread, these can also toast over two times the amount of a standard 4-toast toaster in the same amount of time.

Energy and Time Efficiency

Added options like broiling or convection make the toaster oven an excellent way to get your perfect slice of toast in the morning without the energy of using the full-sized oven. A toaster oven can use over 50% less energy than a full-sized oven, which makes them an efficient alternative for cooking smaller meals, too.

Not only are toaster ovens great for their energy efficiency, but they are also extremely useful in saving time. This appliance is perfect for those early mornings when you are rushing to get out the door. Since they are designed to heat up quickly and to cook your food evenly, toaster ovens can be life savers for your daily routine.

The best toaster oven is the one that works for you. Space, time, and ease of use are all factors in choosing the right toaster oven. A popular choice for many is the Breville Smart Oven Convection Toaster Oven.

Comparable to an Air Fryer

If you are trying to decide between using a toaster oven or an air fryer to toast your bread, the decision comes down to personal preference. The cooking time is typically about the same between the two appliances, and both are more efficient than a full-sized conventional oven.

An air fryer uses convection baking to evenly toast sliced bread. Many toaster ovens also use convection baking to deliver toasted bread a bit more quickly than standard baking.

However, a messy air fryer toast can be a little harder to get out of the fryer once you’re done, due to the bucket-shaped design of many air fryers. And some air fryers can’t be put on countertops, which could be a deal-breaker for people with smaller kitchens.

Not only that, but air fryers on the market today are typically more expensive than most toaster ovens. You can air fry your toast for some unique options for new recipes. But if you’re just looking for an appliance to toast bread, the toaster oven is still the way to go.

Fun With Toast

In most standard toasters, any toppings you want to have on your toast have to be applied after the toast is done cooking, but with toaster ovens, you can pile on as many toppings or condiments as your heart desires.

Whether you want to melt cheese on your toast or want to stack a breakfast sandwich, you can do so without being worried that your toppings will fall off. You can also melt butter on your bread before removing it from the toaster oven or even make it into french toast.

Here are some other easy ideas to up your toast game:

  • Peanut butter and Nutella toast
  • Cinnamon toast
  • Baked French toast
  • Cheesy egg toast
  • Bruschetta toast
  • Garlic bread

If you’re a fan of trying new things, this can be the perfect chance to try your hand at making a signature new dish or copying a recipe from online. Now you can impress your friends and family with your new repertoire of toast recipes! So, how do you make toast in a toaster oven? Well, there are a variety of ways!

The Various Settings on a Toaster Oven Can Help You Achieve Your Desired Toast

Other Uses for Your Toaster Oven

While toaster ovens are, of course, great at making toast, these kitchen appliances are essential appliances for cooking a variety of different foods. Many toaster ovens include options for toasting, baking, and broiling, so the options are limitless as to what you can do.

Some other breakfast items you can make in your toaster include bacon, english muffins, and french toast, but you’re not limited to just breakfast items. Popular other dishes made in toaster ovens are pizza, grilled cheese, salmon, bacon, and french fries.

These handy toasters can also bake your family’s favorite cookies or homemade bread for a more efficient alternative to the full-sized oven with your smaller baking jobs.

Overall, toaster ovens are an incredibly versatile appliance often overlooked for air fryers or microwaves. However, this kitchen tool can increase the quality of your food and has many options included to get your dish just right.

This Toaster Oven by Hamilton Beach Can be Used to Cook Pizza

Frank Salvatore

Hey there - I'm Frank Salvatore. I created this site as a comprehensive kitchen resource. You'll find everything you need to know about everything in your kitchen. From appliances to utensils and layout - it is covered on this site!

About Me
Frank Salvatore
I created this site as a comprehensive kitchen resource. You'll find everything you need to know about everything in your kitchen. From appliances to utensils and layout - it is covered on this site!
Learn More About Me
Related Blog Posts
rocketarrow-downarrow-right linkedin facebook pinterest youtube rss twitter instagram facebook-blank rss-blank linkedin-blank pinterest youtube twitter instagram